How to Be a Great Audience Volunteer at a Magic Show

The Art of the Audience Volunteer — Part One
The magician looks out across the room.
“I need someone to help me with this.”
Suddenly, half the audience has developed a fascination with their shoes. Someone points enthusiastically at their partner. And somewhere near the front, a person who was having a perfectly relaxed evening wonders whether it is too late to hide behind the wine list.
Being an audience volunteer at a magic show can be a wonderful experience. You get the best view, become part of something impossible and leave with a story to tell.
You also don’t need to be funny, outgoing or good at shuffling cards.
Whether you’re keen to take part or would much rather stay in your seat, here’s how to enjoy the moment.
First things first: you’re allowed to say no
An invitation to help is exactly that: an invitation.
If you don’t want to go on stage, a smile and a clear “No, thank you” are enough. You don’t need an excuse, a medical history or evidence of an urgent appointment elsewhere.
If you’re happy to help from your seat, you can say so:
“I’d rather stay here, but I’m happy to choose a card.”
And if you don’t want to participate at all, that’s fine too. Buying a ticket doesn’t oblige you to become part of the performance.
The same courtesy applies to your companions. Before enthusiastically nominating your friend, partner or colleague, remember that enjoying someone’s company isn’t quite the same as having permission to send them on stage.
You don’t need to know how anything works
There is no revision required.
You don’t need to understand magic, recognise a particular playing card or know what a mentalist is about to ask. The performer should explain what they need as you go along.
Usually, your role is straightforward: make a choice, hold an object, remember something or describe what you’ve seen.
Listen, take your time and ask if anything is unclear. “Would you like me to show everyone?” is a perfectly sensible question. So is “Sorry, which hand?”
It’s a magic show. Nobody should be marking your work.
Be yourself — including when you’re surprised
You don’t have to produce a television reaction.
If something astonishes you, let it. If your response is a quiet smile and a baffled shake of the head, that’s equally welcome. There is no obligation to leap backwards, shout or inspect the furniture.
You also don’t need to agree with something that isn’t true. If you’re asked whether that was your card, your word or your freely chosen number, answer honestly.
A genuine response gives the moment its meaning. You’re there as yourself, rather than as an actor who has somehow missed the rehearsal.
Let the performer finish the question
A little nervousness can make us rush. So can the sudden discovery that several dozen people are watching us hold an envelope.
Give yourself a moment.
Listen to the whole instruction before acting, especially if you’re being asked to remember something privately or show an object to the audience. If you miss a detail, ask for it again.
There’s no prize for being the fastest person ever to write down a three-digit number.
Enjoy the joke without feeling obliged to supply one
A spontaneous comment can be one of the best moments in a live show. You don’t have to suppress your personality or become solemn because someone has handed you a pack of cards.
But you don’t need to turn every question into a comedy audition either.
Answering a simple question simply helps the performance move along. If a funny moment happens naturally, enjoy it. The magician can take care of keeping the room entertained.
Your job description does not include “rescue the evening with banter”.
Curiosity is welcome; grabbing the props is less helpful
Of course you want to look. Something peculiar has just happened six inches from your nose.
Handle anything you’ve been invited to handle, and feel free to ask before touching something else. There may be fragile objects, equipment or items belonging to another audience member.
Trying to snatch something away or rummage through the performer’s pockets tends to make the evening awkward surprisingly quickly.
You can be curious without turning the show into a search warrant.
At a mentalism show, keep your boundaries
A mentalist may ask you to think of a person, remember an experience or write something down.
Choose something you’re comfortable bringing into a public performance. There’s no need to reach for your most private memory simply because someone has asked you to think of something meaningful.
If you’re unsure whether an answer will be spoken aloud, ask before sharing it.
You can also say:
“I’d rather choose something else.”
Or:
“I’d prefer not to share that.”
You don’t have to disclose sensitive information to be a good volunteer. The performer should work with your boundaries.
Tell the performer what would help you
If you haven’t heard an instruction, can’t clearly see an object or would find the steps difficult, say so.
You might be perfectly happy to participate from your seat. You might need the magician to stand on your other side, repeat a question or give you a little longer.
You don’t owe the room an explanation of your circumstances. A simple “Could I stay seated?” or “Could you repeat that?” tells the performer what they need to know.
Being a good volunteer doesn’t mean putting up with discomfort.
Changed your mind? You can still stop
Sometimes an invitation sounds enjoyable from your seat and feels rather different once you’re standing in front of everyone.
You’re allowed to change your mind.
“I’d like to sit down now, please” is clear and perfectly reasonable. You can say it quietly to the performer if that feels easier.
And if a joke or request makes you uncomfortable, you don’t have to laugh along to keep the show moving. Making the experience work is the performer’s responsibility too.
If you’re staying in the audience, you still have a part to play
Give volunteers the kind of welcome you would appreciate yourself.
Applaud them as they come up. Let them answer for themselves. Resist shouting instructions, supplying their punchlines or announcing that they’re “always like this”.
Someone who looks confident may be feeling nervous. A warm audience can make an enormous difference.
And when they return to their seat, let them enjoy their moment. They’ve just helped create something the whole room shared.
The secret to being a great volunteer
You don’t need a big personality, a clever line or nerves of steel.
Be yourself, listen, answer honestly and say what you’re comfortable with. That’s plenty.
A good magical moment comes from the relationship between the performer, the volunteer and the audience. When everyone feels at ease, there’s room for surprise, laughter and that lovely pause when nobody is quite sure what just happened.
Even the person who was studying the wine list.
Keep the magic going
Know someone who loves a magic show but dreads being picked? Share this article with them before your next night out.
And if you’re curious about the people on the other side of the trick, discover The Order of The Magi, Manchester’s oldest magic society. Explore our programme of magic lectures and club events, or find out about becoming a member.
Next in this two-part series: How to Be Great to Your Volunteers — how magicians and mentalists can help the people who join them on stage feel welcome, confident and appreciated.