Volunterers
How to Be Great to Your Volunteers: A Guide for Magicians and Mentalists
The Art of the Audience Volunteer — Part Two
You know what’s in the envelope. You know where the routine is going. You’ve probably delivered that line about the wedding ring a hundred times.
The person standing beside you knows considerably less. Including, quite possibly, why they agreed to come up.
In part one, we looked at being an audience volunteer, including how to decline the invitation. This time, we’re looking at the person doing the inviting.
Because once someone joins you on stage, you’ve taken on a responsibility. They’re lending you their time, their trust and, for a few minutes, a fair amount of control over how the room sees them.
Look after that.
Make it an invitation they can actually decline
“Would you like to help?” is a perfectly good question, provided you’re prepared to accept the answer.
If someone says no, thank them and move on. No disappointed face. No “Oh, come on.” And certainly no recruiting the audience to chant until resistance becomes more embarrassing than participation.
They may have a reason. You don’t need to know it.
Watch the less obvious responses too: the person shrinking into their seat, shaking their head or smiling while clearly wishing you’d choose somebody else. A nervous smile isn’t necessarily a yes.
And if a whole table points at one person, check with that person. Their colleagues haven’t acquired booking rights over them.
Give them a decent arrival
Getting from a seat to the performing area can feel surprisingly exposed. People are watching. There may be steps, cables or a chair leg determined to have its own moment.
Give your volunteer time to get there. Show them the route and where you’d like them to stand. Offer help if it’s needed, and ask before taking an arm or guiding them by the shoulder.
Then greet them.
A proper hello, a name and a moment of ordinary human contact can settle things far more effectively than launching straight into your opening gag. If you ask their name, listen to it. Use it correctly.
They’ve only just arrived. Let them land.
Explain the small things
“Stand over there.”
Where?
The spot you’ve used throughout rehearsals is obvious to you. Your volunteer may be trying to work out whether you mean beside the table, behind it or somewhere near the fire exit.
Be specific and pleasant. “Just here, beside me, so everyone can see you” does the job.
The same applies to instructions involving cards, envelopes, writing and objects. Say what you need in manageable steps. If they’re supposed to keep something hidden, tell them before they turn it towards the front row.
It’s much easier than trying to retrieve a secret from forty people who have just read it.
And when an instruction goes astray, take a moment to consider whether you explained it clearly. “I should have made that clearer” will often serve you better than “No, I said your other hand.”
Let the audience see someone worth liking
You have a microphone, prepared material and the advantage of knowing what happens next. Your volunteer has none of those things.
That’s quite a head start.
There’s plenty of room for humour, including playful exchanges with someone who’s clearly enjoying themselves. But pay attention to where the laugh lands. Are they sharing it? Or waiting for you to finish so they can escape?
A joke about your own inability to organise three envelopes is usually a safer bet than a joke about their ability to count them.
Some volunteers are wonderfully quick. Enjoy that. Give them the laugh they’ve earned, rather than reaching for a line that puts them back in their place.
You’re allowed to be the second funniest person on stage for a moment. The act will survive.
Don’t confuse cooperation with comfort
Most people are polite.
They’ll laugh when they’re unsure, agree when they haven’t quite heard and put up with something awkward because they don’t want to disrupt the show.
That makes it easy to miss discomfort if you’re busy watching for the next cue.
Look at the person beside you. Have they become unusually quiet? Are they pulling away, hesitating or looking towards their seat? A brief, quiet check can give them room to tell you what they need.
And make the options real.
You might continue with them seated, change the request or thank them and find someone else. If they ask to stop, help them do so gracefully. They shouldn’t have to negotiate their release from a card trick.
Be careful what you ask people to reveal
Mentalism can give apparently simple questions a considerable amount of weight.
“Think of someone important to you.”
You may be expecting a name and a neat revelation. They may be thinking of someone who died last month.
You can’t anticipate every association. You can, however, give people a comfortable starting point and permission to change their minds. Asking for a happy memory they’d be willing to discuss publicly gives them more guidance than “Think of the most emotional moment of your life.”
Be clear about what may be revealed. Writing something down can feel private even when the eventual plan is to announce it to the room.
Take particular care with routines involving relationships, money, health or personal history. The fact that a method allows you to reveal something doesn’t settle whether you should.
If an answer takes you somewhere sensitive, resist the temptation to make the most of it. The routine can wait.
Physical contact shouldn’t be a surprise
If you need someone to hold out a hand, close their eyes or allow you to touch their shoulder, explain what you’re asking.
Then ask.
Do the same before borrowing jewellery, inspecting clothing or reaching towards a pocket. Something may be entirely innocent within the mechanics of your routine and still feel intrusive to the person experiencing it.
Think through the practical details in advance. Can this be done with less contact? Can they remove the ring themselves? Is there an alternative if they’d rather keep their eyes open?
A well-prepared alternative saves everyone from that strained little pause when “Are you comfortable with this?” turns out to have only one acceptable answer.
Give them something they can do well
Your volunteer shouldn’t need specialist handling skills or the memory of a competition finalist to get through the routine.
If a task is difficult, simplify it. If it needs demonstration, demonstrate it. And if hearing, sight, mobility or language makes an instruction awkward, adapt without turning the adjustment into an announcement.
They don’t owe the audience an explanation.
This matters in close-up work too. Someone seated at a dinner table may have very little room to handle cards, somewhere inconvenient to put a drink and three people talking behind them. Conditions which seem perfectly reasonable from your side of the table may be rather less helpful from theirs.
Give them time. Silence while someone follows an instruction can feel much longer to the performer than it does to everyone else.
You don’t always need to fill it.
When something goes wrong, share the load
A card gets shown too soon. A number is forgotten. Someone misunderstands which envelope to open.
It happens.
Your response tells the audience how to treat the person involved. If you sound irritated, the room may become uncomfortable. If you stay calm and help them through it, most people will happily come with you.
Sometimes a light line is enough. Sometimes you need a different route through the effect. Occasionally, you need to abandon it.
None of those options requires making your volunteer look foolish.
It’s worth rehearsing the awkward versions of a routine as well as the successful one. What will you say if they don’t remember? What if they disagree with your revelation? What if they want to sit down halfway through?
An alternative you’ve considered beforehand is much easier to deliver kindly.
Finish their part properly
You’ve reached the revelation. The audience reacts. You’re already thinking about the next effect.
Your volunteer is still standing there.
Thank them by name. Give them credit for helping and invite the audience to applaud. Make it clear that they can return to their seat, and help with the route if necessary.
Check that borrowed belongings have gone back to their owners. A missing watch has a way of distracting people from your carefully constructed finale.
If they’ve been holding something, take it from them before they start navigating the steps. And let the applause belong to them for a moment.
They’ve earned it.
What will they say at the interval?
We spend a lot of time thinking about what an audience will remember: the signed card, the impossible prediction, the borrowed object appearing somewhere ridiculous.
It’s worth thinking about what your volunteer will say afterwards, too.
Will they be delighted that they took part? Will they be showing someone a souvenir, describing the moment or laughing about their own reaction?
Or will they be explaining that they didn’t really want to go up, but felt they couldn’t refuse?
You can’t guarantee that everyone will enjoy being on stage. You can give them clear choices, treat them with warmth and notice when something needs to change.
Then they have a much better chance of enjoying the impossible thing you’ve worked so hard to show them.
And you have a much better chance of being remembered fondly by the person who saw it closest.
Bring the conversation to The Magi
Before your next performance, run through one routine from your volunteer’s point of view. Look at what you ask them to do, what they know at each stage and where they might feel uncertain. You may find a small change that makes the whole routine better.
Conversations like these are a good reason to spend time with other magicians. If you’d like to share ideas, develop your performing and meet others who care about the craft, find out about joining The Order of The Magi, Manchester’s oldest magic society.
Bring your experience. Bring your questions.
We’ve all given an instruction that made perfect sense until somebody tried to follow it.
